Categories > Guides and Tips

top-cavendish-restaurants-banner

Feast Like a Local at These Top 15 Cavendish PEI Restaurants

Clever Canadian Written By: January 2025

You’ve finally crossed that “Anne of Green Gables” experience off your bucket list, and as you take in the sights, the wonder sinks in… along with your glucose levels since you haven’t eaten anything yet. 

But hey, don’t worry—let’s cap off your Cavendish adventure with a meal that’ll make up for all that time spent sightseeing on an empty stomach. Cavendish doesn’t run short of good food. I mean, PEI is basically a seafood haven (and then some), so you’re bound to find a great catch—no pun intended. 

Whether you’re craving lobster, fish tacos, or something a little unexpected, you’ll find plenty of delicious options here. Here’s a list of the best restaurants in Cavendish—because after all that exploring, you deserve to eat like a local.

The Ship’s Company Pub & Galley

Media from lorithebeth

Address: 8863 Cavendish Rd
Contact details: +1 902-360-2124
Opening hours: Wednesday to Monday: 12 PM to 8 PM
Pricing: $$
Facebook
Menu

The Ship’s Company Pub & Galley feels like a true maritime hangout in the heart of Cavendish. The menu leans heavily into PEI’s seafood bounty, with staples like fish and chips, seafood chowder, and whatever’s fresh off the boat that day.  

The decor adds to the character—think vintage ship memorabilia and a nautical theme that doesn’t feel overdone. It’s the kind of place where you can bring the family, meet up with friends, or even mark a special occasion without it feeling overly fancy. 

Not to mention, the portions are hearty, and there are little twists on the classics that make the dishes feel familiar yet interesting.

Pro tip:

Arrive during lunchtime for fewer crowds and a chance to grab their lobster chowder before it sells out. Pair your meal with a locally brewed ale for a quintessential PEI experience.

Captain Kidd’s Dairy Bar & Takeout

Media from  superfunkomatic

Address: Cavendish Rd 8528 rt6
Contact details: +1 (902)963-3738
Opening hours: Monday to Sunday: 11 AM to 9 PM
Pricing: $
Website
Menu

If you’re ever near the beach, Captain Kidd’s Dairy Bar & Takeout is a must-try. The ice cream cones are massive and perfect for a warm day, but they also do great fried clams, fries, and burgers—just solid, comforting food. 

There’s outdoor seating, so it’s great for families, and the kids can run around while you kick back and enjoy the meal. The staff are super friendly, and you don’t have to wait long. 

People rave about how fresh the seafood is and how many ice cream flavours there are, from the usual favourites to some fun seasonal ones.

Pro tip:

Visit early evening to catch the sunset while enjoying your meal.

BeaverTails

Media from intuitivebeautymichelle

Address: 8619 PE-6, Green Gables
Contact details: +1 902-963-3939
Opening hours: Monday to Sunday: 9 AM to 5 PM
Pricing: $
Website
Menu

If you’re in Cavendish, you have to grab a BeaverTail, especially the one near Green Gables. They’re always fresh and hot, and you can get them with all sorts of toppings, from the classic cinnamon sugar to Nutella and banana if you’re feeling indulgent. 

It’s the perfect spot to take a break, whether with the family or just strolling around. They’ve got outdoor seating, so you can enjoy your treat and take in the view. 

Seriously, whether it’s your first BeaverTail or your tenth, it’s always a solid choice.

Pro tip:

Go for a seasonal topping when available—they often include local flavors unique to PEI.

Island Chef at the Pier

Media from islandchefatthepier

Address: 9796 Cavendish Rd RTE 6
Contact details: +1 902-916-8139
Opening hours: Monday to Sunday: 4 PM to 8:30 PM
Pricing: $$
Website
Menu

Island Chef at the Pier is one of those places that really nails the whole PEI vibe. It’s right by the water, so you get those gorgeous views while enjoying super fresh seafood.

The scallop risotto? So creamy and packed with flavor. And you have to try the lobster-stuffed mushrooms – they’re incredible. Whether you’re just out for a casual dinner or celebrating something special, it’s the perfect spot because it feels relaxed but still has that special touch.

They also do events and have these amazing wedding packages with all-local, fresh ingredients. Honestly, between the views and the food, it’s no wonder people keep coming back!

Pro tip:

Dinner reservations are highly recommended, especially during peak tourist season. Don’t skip the lobster poutine—it’s a standout dish you won’t find anywhere else.

Chez Yvonne’s

Media from chezyvonnes

Address: 8947 PE-6, New Glasgow
Contact details: +1 902-963-2070
Opening hours: 

  • Monday to Friday: 12 PM to 7 PM
  • Saturday to Sunday: 8 AM to 7 PM

Pricing: $$
Website
Menu

For over 50 years, Chez Yvonne’s has been serving hearty meals with a side of genuine hospitality. This family-run gem features an expansive menu that caters to every taste, from seafood platters and sizzling steaks to all-day breakfast favourites. 

The homey decor and welcoming vibe make it a hit with families and regulars alike. Portions are generous, and the flavours are comforting, reflecting recipes perfected over decades. 

We even saw how guests frequently praise their attention to detail and friendly service, which keeps them coming back. 

Pro tip:

Breakfast tends to be the busiest, so arrive early for a table. Don’t leave without trying a slice of their famous coconut cream pie.

Tim Hortons

Media from timhortons

Address: 7550 Cavendish Rd
Contact details: +1 902-963-2594
Opening hours: Monday to Sunday: 7 AM to 8 PM
Pricing: $
Website
Menu

Yes, it’s Canada’s favourite coffee chain, but the Tim Hortons in Cavendish is the perfect place for a quick refuel between adventures. Whether you’re fueling up before a day of exploring or stopping by for a break, their menu has something for everyone. 

Classic options like the double-double coffee, Timbits, and breakfast sandwiches are popular picks. Seasonal favourites like pumpkin spice lattes or peppermint mochas bring variety, while the reliable chilli and soups hit the spot on cooler days. 

And we have to say, the casual atmosphere and quick service make it an easy choice for families or groups on the go.

Pro tip:

Download their app for exclusive deals and rewards. Try the maple-glazed donut for a quintessential Canadian treat.

The Lost Anchor

Media from lostanchorpei

Address: 8572 Cavendish Rd, New Glasgow
Contact details: +1 902-360-2221
Opening hours: 

  • Sunday to Thursday: 12 PM to 9 PM
  • Friday to Saturday: 12 PM to 10 PM

Pricing: $$
Website
Menu

Right in the heart of Cavendish, The Lost Anchor is the kind of spot that feels like a little hidden gem. They’re all about fresh seafood and comfort, which makes it easy to relax and enjoy. 

Their lobster rolls are buttery and delicious, the mussels are perfectly steamed, and if seafood isn’t your thing, they’ve got you covered with burgers and fries that hit the spot. The outdoor patio is the place to be in the summer, especially on nights with live music—it just adds to the whole experience. 

With friendly staff and locally sourced ingredients, everything feels thoughtful and welcoming. Whether you’re stopping by for lunch or winding down with dinner after exploring Cavendish, it’s one of those places that always leave you happy.

Pro tip:

Their weekly specials often include unique creations not found on the regular menu. Visit during happy hour for discounted drinks and appetizers.

Tide & Tales Bistro and Bookstore

Media from _tideandtales_

Address: 32 Harbourview Dr, North Rustico
Contact details: +1 902-963-3212
Opening hours: Monday to Sunday: 8 AM – 8 PM
Pricing: $$
Website
Menu

Tide & Tales is such a gem, especially if you’re into good food and great books. This cozy little bistro has the perfect vibe for slowing down and enjoying the moment. Their smoked salmon bagels, hearty soups, and fresh scones are so satisfying, especially with a good cup of coffee or tea. 

The best part? The bookshelves! You can browse, find a new favourite, and even start reading right there while you eat. 

It’s more than just a place to grab a bite—it’s a hangout spot for book lovers, with author events and book club meetups happening pretty often. You’ll probably find yourself staying longer than you’d expect.

Pro tip:

Check their event schedule for author readings or book club meetups. Their homemade scones stand out and sell out quickly, so order one early.

Blue Mussel Cafe

Media from bluemusselcafe

Address: 312 Harbourview Dr, North Rustico
Contact details: +1 902-963-2152
Opening hours: 

  • Sunday to Thursday: 11:30 AM to 8 PM
  • Friday to Saturday: 11:30 AM to 9 PM

Pricing: $$
Website
Menu

The Blue Mussel Café is a seasonal seafood spot in North Rustico Harbour, tucked just far enough off the beaten path to feel like a find. Everything on the menu is fresh and local—caught, harvested, or raised just hours before it lands on your plate. 

They’ve got amazing options like lobster mac and cheese, creamy seafood chowder, and pan-seared scallops, and there’s no deep-fried food in sight. It’s all about authentic PEI flavours served up in a way that feels wholesome and satisfying. 

And the view? It’s breathtaking, especially at sunset—it’s the kind of view that stays with you. With great food, friendly staff, and a cozy vibe, it’s a place you’ll want to keep coming back to.

Pro tip:

They don’t take reservations, so aim to arrive before the dinner rush to secure a table. Try their daily specials for the freshest flavours of the season.

Fisherman’s Wharf Lobster Suppers

Media from fishermanswharf15

Address: 7230 Rustico Rd, North Rustico
Contact details: +1 902-963-2669
Opening hours: Monday to Sunday: 11 AM to 10 PM
Pricing: $$
Website
Menu

No visit to Prince Edward Island is complete without a stop at the World Famous Fisherman’s Wharf in North Rustico. This iconic spot is home to the 60 ft salad bar, all-you-can-eat mussels, and their famous seafood chowder. 

Of course, the star of the show is the lobster—steamed to perfection and served with drawn butter. The atmosphere is lively and welcoming, with communal tables where locals and visitors alike share in the experience.

For those looking for more options, Pier 15 also offers a full à la carte menu. And don’t forget to check out the gift shop for great souvenirs to remember your visit. 

Pro tip:

The early dinner special is great for avoiding crowds and saving a bit. Bring your appetite; the portions are generous, and the mussels are unlimited!

MOO MOO BBQ Grilled Cheesery – Avonlea Village

Media from moomoobbqgrilledcheesery

Address: 8779 Cavendish Rd
Contact details: +1 902-963-2438
Opening hours: Monday to Sunday: 11 AM to 8 PM
Pricing: $$
Website
Menu

Grilled cheese lovers, get ready—MOO MOO BBQ in Avonlea Village is here to blow your mind. This isn’t your everyday grilled cheese. Think thick, golden-brown slices of artisan bread stuffed with gooey cheese and topped with BBQ pulled pork or smoky brisket that melts in your mouth. 

Every bite is comfort food heaven, especially with a side of crispy fries or tangy coleslaw to keep things balanced. The setting is just as good as the food—outdoor seating surrounded by the charming, storybook vibes of Avonlea Village. 

And we have to say: you can really kick back, indulge, and soak up the fun atmosphere, whether you’re exploring with family or just following your cravings.

Pro tip:

The brisket grilled cheese is the star of the menu, so make sure to give it a try. Seating is limited, so consider taking your meal to go during busy times.

Turkey Tavern

Media from turkeytavern

Address: 8779 PE-6
Contact details: +1 902-360-1988
Opening hours: Monday to Sunday: 11:30 AM to 7 PM
Pricing: $$
Website
Menu

If you’re in Cavendish, you’ve got to swing by Turkey Tavern. The food feels like a warm welcome like you’re sitting down for a home-cooked meal. 

True to its name, they really get creative with turkey here—think turkey poutine, turkey burgers, and turkey pot pie. They even have cranberry-infused salads that hit the spot. 

Plus, the staff is friendly, making you feel right at home. After a day of sightseeing or whenever you’re craving something filling, this is the spot. And the best part? You can enjoy turkey year-round, with plenty of options to choose from.

Pro tip:

The Thanksgiving platter is incredibly popular—arrive early to snag it. Pair your meal with their house-made cranberry sauce for the full experience.

Quick Fire International Cuisine

Media from quickfireinternationalcuisine

Address: 8989 Cavendish Rd
Contact details: +1 782-377-3611
Opening hours: Tuesday to Sunday: 11:30 AM to 9 PM
Pricing: $$
Website
Menu

Quick Fire in Cavendish is a great spot when you’re craving something with a little more flavour. The menu mixes things up with everything from zesty tacos to delicious stir-fries and Mediterranean kebabs. 

You can expect that each dish is packed with taste, and you can tell they really put thought into it. The counter service makes it easy to grab a meal without the wait, and the portions are super generous. 

People love how flavorful everything is, and it’s just a really solid choice when you’re looking for something different and satisfying.

Pro tip:

Their daily specials are an excellent way to try something off the beaten path. Ask about spice levels if you’re not accustomed to bold flavours.

Piatto Pizzeria

Media from piattopizzeria

Address: 8779 Cavendish Rd, New Glasgow
Contact details: +1 902-360-0909
Opening hours: Monday to Sunday: 11:30 AM to 8 PM
Pricing: $$
Website
Menu

Piatto in Cavendish serves up a taste of Naples with its wood-fired pizzas that are hard to beat. The pizzas are made with fresh, top-quality ingredients and cooked to perfection in a traditional oven. 

The Margherita and Prosciutto Arugula are always crowd-pleasers, but don’t miss out on the seasonal specials—they’re always worth trying. 

And the ambiance strikes the perfect balance between relaxed and a little upscale, making it a great spot for a family meal or a casual date night.

Pro tip:

Save room for their Nutella pizza—it’s a decadent way to end your meal. Their gluten-free crust is also highly rated by diners with dietary restrictions.

Pedro’s Island Eatery

Media from flemmingtonsteele

Address: 7208 Main St, North Rustico
Contact details: +1 902-963-2039
Opening hours: 

  • Thursday to Friday: 4 PM – 8 PM
  • Saturday: 8 AM – 12 PM, 4 PM – 8 PM
  • Sunday: 8 AM – 12 PM, 4 PM – 7 PM

Pricing: $$
Facebook
Menu

If you’re ever in North Rustico, you’ve got to check out Pedro’s Island Eatery. It’s not just a restaurant—it’s a real taste of PEI. They focus on fresh, locally sourced ingredients, and everything on the menu, from the lobster rolls to the chowders, is packed with flavour. 

The atmosphere is cozy, and the staff is so friendly, making it a perfect spot whether you’re out with family or enjoying a quiet dinner. 

And definitely pair your meal with one of their local craft beers or wines—you won’t regret it. It’s open for breakfast on weekends and dinner during the week, so there’s always a good reason to stop by.

Pro tip:

Arrive early for breakfast to beat the rush. Their seafood chowder is highly recommended for a taste of the region.

Related topics