Categories > Guides and Tips

10 Best Consignment Stores in Toronto

10 Best Consignment Stores in Toronto

Looking to elevate your wardrobe without breaking the bank? Toronto’s consignment stores are the city’s fashion gems, offering a curated collection of pre-loved treasures. 

From unique picks to second-hand chic, these establishments prove that style doesn’t have to put you into debt. Let’s dive into the world of Toronto’s best consignment stores, where fashion meets frugality in the most fabulous way possible.

Common Sort

Media from commonsort

Address: 444 Bloor St W, Toronto, ON M5S 1X8, other locations

Contact details: (416) 532-5990

Opening hours: Monday to Saturday: 11:00 AM – 7:00 PM; Sunday: 11:00 AM – 6:00 PM

Website

Common Sort, with its trio of Toronto spots, is a consignment gem you can’t afford to miss. Here’s the scoop: they’ll happily take your gently used threads and toss you 25% cash or 50% store credit based on their selling price. 

It’s not just a vintage haven; they’ve got a treasure trove of premium brands like Marc Jacobs, Jimmy Choo, and Kate Spade. And here’s the kicker – since they source everything straight from savvy sellers, the stock is ever-evolving. 

Spot something dazzling? Don’t hesitate – snag it pronto because lightning might not strike twice!

Pro tip:

  • For sellers, the wait time at Waits ranges from 20 minutes to 3 hours, depending on the number of drop-offs. Keep in mind that authenticating designer clothing may take a bit longer.
  • No refunds, but exchanges are cool if the item’s got its tag, stays in mint condition, you’ve got the receipt, and it’s within two weeks of your purchase.

VSP Consignment

Media from vsp.consignment

Address: 1410 Dundas St W, Toronto, ON M6J 1Y5

Contact details: 416-588-9821

Opening hours: Tuesday to Saturday: 10:00 AM – 6:00 PM

Website

Hey, if you’re on the hunt for upscale consignment goodies, VSP Consignment in Toronto is where it’s at. Think Rag & Bone, Chanel, Christian Louboutin—total gems, all in mint condition. 

And get this – you can get a hold of items as recent as last season. Plus, the store’s got that sleek, minimal vibe. 

On top of that, there’s no need to break a sweat hunting for treasures; they practically jump out at you. Forget the usual consignment drill; VSP is all about easy elegance. 

Pro tips:

  • To sell, swing by the shop on any weekday without an appointment, and they’ll offer you 50% of the selling price. 
  • Visit their website and grab the 10% off deal for your first order.

The Comeback Consignment

Media from thecomebackconsignment

Address: 4893 Dundas St W, Etobicoke, ON M9A 1B2

Contact details: 416-231-0381

Opening hours: Wednesday to Sunday: 10:00 AM – 6:00 PM

Website 

Moving on to the next one, The Comeback Consignment is a go-to spot for a diverse range of styles, from wallet-friendly to high-end brands like Zara, Lululemon, and Mackage. They’ve been curating fantastic pieces with a chic vibe for over four decades.

Here’s the deal: if you’re planning to part ways with some fashion treasures, The Comeback will slide you 15-70% of the value, depending on how they price things.

And the best part is that their store near Islington and Burnhamthorpe in Etobicoke is the place to be for this shopping escapade. 

Pro tips:

  • Stay connected and catch their latest arrivals by tuning in on Facebook and Instagram Live. Shop from the cozy comfort of your living room, patio, or bedroom.
  • Quick tip: Online orders are final sale, so choose wisely. But if you snag something in-store, you’ve got a one-business-day window for returns. 

Extoggery

Media from theextoggery

Address: 10 Brentcliffe Rd, East York, ON M4G 3Y2

Contact details: +1 416-696-6700

Opening hours: Monday to Tuesday and Thursday to Saturday: 10:00 AM – 6:00 PM; Sunday: 12:00 PM – 5:00 PM

Website

Hang out in Toronto’s Leaside neighbourhood, and you’ll stumble upon Extoggery, a designer consignment spot flaunting brands like Madewell, Tory Burch, Louis Vuitton, Canada Goose, Alexander McQueen, and more. 

With a stylish legacy of 77 years, Extoggery is your fashion hub for snagging killer deals on brand-name threads, women’s wear, and men’s accessories. 

Oh, and here’s the heartwarming part: any clothing that doesn’t find a new home within about two months, pay it forward by donating. So, not only do you score some serious style steals, but you’re part of a fashion cycle that gives back. 

Pro tip:

  • Note that your clothes grace their racks for 60 days. You’ll see a swift 45% of the retail selling price in your account when they’re sold.
  • Just a heads-up, you’ve got options for grabbing your cash or cheque in-store—cash for anything under $100 and a cheque for amounts over. If swinging by isn’t your thing, you can ask for a cheque by mail, but there’s a small $5 fee for the convenience.

Consign Toronto

Media from dagsvintageshop

Address: 458 Oakwood Ave #201, Toronto, ON M6W 2E5

Contact details: +1 416 618 1412

Opening hours: Tuesday to Saturday: 11:00 AM– 6:00 PM

Website

Check it out—Consign Toronto’s got both men’s and women’s threads, becoming a local fave in the neighbourhood. They’re all about catering to different sizes, offering prices from $35-50 to a cool $2,000. 

And get this, they’re not skimping on the glam—Chanel, Dior, Balenciaga, Gucci, you name it. Even those elusive accessories like earrings and sleeve cuffs are in the mix. 

Plus, there’s no need for appointments, and you could pocket up to 70% back on your items. 

Pro tip:

  • We suggest swinging by their website for an exclusive peek at the latest arrivals before they vanish.  

Fashionably Yours

Media from shopfy

Address: 707 Queen St W, Toronto, ON M6J 1E6

Contact details: +1 647-802-9687

Opening hours: Tuesday and Thursday to Saturday: 12:00 PM – 7:00 PM; Wednesday: 12:00 PM – 6:00 PM; Sunday: 12:00 PM – 5:00 PM

Website 

Discover the epitome of posh at Fashionably Yours, right in the heart of Queen West – the second coolest neighbourhood in the world, as Vogue puts it. 

They’ve got both men’s and women’s fashion and accessories, including a wallet-friendly section under $200 for those who aren’t big on splurging. Here’s the cool part: they teamed up with NYC fine artist Sue Tsai for an exclusive limited edition racerback and print. 

What sets them apart, though, is the online game – you can place orders through PayPal with free shipping in Canada and the U.S. Talk about style delivered to your doorstep! 

Pro tips:

  • Here’s the deal: they’ll set a new selling price, and when your item sells, you both get a 50/50 split. Plus, with their online system, you can easily track your sales. 
  • If your item hasn’t found a buyer after 120 days, you have the option to pick it up or donate it.

Clementine’s

Media from clementinesluxury

Address: 1054 Yonge St, Toronto, ON M4W 2L1

Contact details: 416-966-2662

Opening hours: Tuesday to Wednesday: 12:00 Pm – 6:00 PM; Thursday to Friday: 11:00 AM – 6:00 PM; Saturday: 11:00 AM – 5:00 PM

Website

Have you ever heard of Clementine’s? It’s not your typical store—it’s this cool concept spot mixing up consigned designer goodies with fresh, ready-to-wear stuff. 

You’ll find it on Yonge St., a few blocks south of St. Clair in the Summerhill neighbourhood. Picture this: Alexander McQueen, Etro, David Yurman, Miu Miu, and more—all under one roof. 

But here’s the extra cool part—Christina McDowell, the owner, is not just any owner; she’s a luxury industry pro, doing image consulting and personal shopping. If you fancy a stylish shopping spree with expert advice, then Clementine’s is the spot! 

Pro tip:

  • Don’t skip the good stuff—check out their website for awesome sales and new arrivals you wouldn’t want to miss.
  • If you change your mind, you can return your item within seven days of getting it. Just make sure it’s in its original condition, packaging, and still rocking those tags. 

I Miss You Vintage

Media from imissyouvintage

Address: 63 Ossington Ave Unit K, Toronto, ON M6J 2Z2 

Contact details: 416-916-7021

Opening hours: Wednesday to Sunday: 12:00 PM – 6:00 PM

Website

We suggest swinging by the hip Ossington strip and diving into the vintage vibes at I Miss You Vintage. Not only are the prices wallet-friendly in this consignment hotspot, but you might snag some fashion gems with history. 

When your item sells for over $100, you’ll pocket a cool 50%. Picture this: Chanel, Gucci, Fendi, Zimmerman, Acne Studios, Yves Saint Laurent—yeah, they’ve got the good stuff. 

It’s all about trendy and modern pieces from the big runway names and contemporary designers. 

Pro tips:

  • Don’t forget to include any extra bits like dusters, boxes, authenticity cards, receipts, and paperwork – these boost the resale value.
  • They only take things with brand names, not from malls. Items must be less than five years old, match current fashion, and be in new or like-new condition. 
  • No vintage stuff (over 20 years old) unless it’s a recognized designer and still trendy or has collector value. 

Bag Religion

Media from bagreligion

Address: 147 Liberty St, Toronto, ON M6K 3G3

Contact details: 416 903 9919 

Opening hours: Monday to Friday 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM

Website

Bag Religion welcomes you with a fantastic range of snazzy designer bags, shoes, and clothing. Their collection of luxurious coats is worth a shoutout, especially since they’re available at a fraction of the original price—an enticing savings opportunity!

Adding to the appeal, Bag Religion offers a Lifetime Money-Back Authenticity Guarantee on all their items, instilling confidence in every purchase. It’s more than just a shopping experience; it’s a commitment to authenticity and quality. 

Whether you’re after a chic bag or a lavish coat, Bag Religion promises top-notch fashion finds with a guarantee of genuine style. 

Pro tip:

  • Here’s the scoop: it’s first come, first served. That way, everyone in the fashion crew gets a fair shot at grabbing those unique finds. Be speedy and get your one-of-a-kind item!
  • Because they operate on consignment, once your order sells, they send all deposits and payments to the consigner to start processing. After this, there are no refunds—sales are final.

Garb

Media from garbconsignment

Address: 1046 Queen St W, Toronto, ON M6J 1H7

Contact details: 416-588-2121

Opening hours: Tuesday to Sunday: 12:00 PM – 6:00 PM

Website

Whether you’re into women’s or men’s styles, Garb has you covered with the latest and greatest labels. Here’s the deal: if you decide to consign with them, you’re looking at a sweet 50% off each item sold.

Imagine flipping through racks featuring the likes of Marc Jacobs, Manolo Blahnik, Gucci, and Christian Louboutin—all in one place. It’s not just about women’s fashion; they’ve also got a collection of luxury second-hand pieces for men, including Burberry and Comme Des Garcons.

Garb is all about embracing luxury, from top-tier designer labels to homegrown Canadian talent and mid- to high-range brands like ACNE and Rag & Bone. And to keep things straightforward, they’ve got a nifty list on their website with the brands they vibe with. 

Pro tip:

  • Get this: when your item sells, you pocket a decent 50%. And if it doesn’t find a new home within 90 days, just swing by the store to pick it up. 

With a mix of luxury finds and sustainable chic, these consignment stores promise not only style but also a unique way to embrace Toronto’s fashion culture. Elevate your wardrobe sustainably and discover the city’s hidden fashion treasures. 

It also applies if you’d rather sell your items than store them somewhere or accidentally throw them away in the junk.

Related topics